counts-change-with-radius

A head is a set of points

The nth primordium at n times an angle, and a radius of root n. Two lines of arithmetic produce a sunflower head, which is either remarkable or suspicious depending on how carefully the claim is stated — and stating it carefully is most of the work.

A stem is a cylinder

The sunflower is the photograph, and it is the hard case. Nearly all real phyllotaxis happens on a stem, where the geometry is a lattice on a cylinder with two parameters — and where the spiral counts, which on a disc change with radius, are the same the whole way up.

Fibonacci is a branch, not a law

Fibonacci counts come from one branch of the model. The Lucas branch — which the same rule reaches at a different growth rate — gives 47 and 76, and neither is a Fibonacci number. The sequence is a consequence of an angle rather than a property of plants.

Packing and tiling

Why the average cell has six sides

Not because hexagons are efficient. Because Euler's formula leaves a tiling no choice — count the edges two ways and the mean comes out at six, whatever the cells would prefer. The efficiency argument is a different claim about a different thing.

Counting the spirals

Almost every claim about phyllotaxis is a claim about how many spirals run through a pattern, and the count is almost never done. It can be done from the points alone, by machinery that is never told what angle built them — and then a count of 34 is evidence rather than a restatement.

The counts change with radius

The same head gives 13 and 21 near the centre, 21 and 34 further out, 34 and 55 beyond that, and 55 and 89 at the rim. The transitions are at computable radii, and a photograph captioned with one pair is a statement about one annulus rather than about a flower.

Two numbers out of the points

A seed head's divergence angle can be recovered from its spiral counts only to within an interval, because a range of angles gives the same counts. On a stem the counts come with lengths attached, two measurements pin two unknowns, and the lattice comes back to the last digit it was built with.

Packing and tiling

Lewis's law wants disorder

Cell area rises linearly with side count — measured on cucumber epidermis in 1928 and quoted ever since as a property of packed tissue. It holds beautifully on a random point set, with a fitted constant of 1.64 against Lewis's 2. On a phyllotactic head it does not hold at all: the slope is 0.009, and area and side count are almost independent.

Recovering the angle from the counts

Build a head at a stated divergence angle, forget the angle, and get it back from the spiral counts alone. Four angles, worst error twelve thousandths of a degree — and the only thing that crossed between the two halves was a list of coordinates.

A disc is a cylinder

Vogel's seed head makes the rise fall as one over radius squared, so a disc is not one lattice but a family of them. Feed that into the cylinder's ladder and it predicts where a sunflower's spiral counts change — with nothing fitted, and against a counter that never sees either model.

Packing and tiling

Two laws that want opposite tissue

Lewis's law and Aboav's relation are quoted side by side as properties of cellular tissue. Measured on the same two tilings they point opposite ways — the ordered head satisfies Aboav's with the textbook value of 1.18 and fails Lewis's completely; the random set does exactly the reverse.

A cone has a rise that falls

A stem holds one parastichy pair for ever and a seed head changes its pair with radius. A cone does both — it is a cylinder whose rise falls as one over the distance from the apex, and the same blind counter that finds one answer up a stem finds four up a cone.

What a count is worth

A reported parastichy pair pins the divergence angle to a band 221°/mn wide — so 2 and 3 says almost nothing and 34 and 55 fixes it to a tenth of a degree. Every rung of the ladder is worth a factor of φ², and the counting radius this collection has asked published counts for since its foundation adds ten per cent.

Why a cone can be counted once

A pineapple is described as 8 and 13 and the description holds. A sunflower is described as 34 and 55 and the description is a statement about one annulus. Both organs have the same ladder in element number — what differs is where an organ puts its elements.

The survey this site cannot do

Four phases of asking for a dataset, and it is still not here. What this phase can do instead is specify it — the fields, the sampling, the sizes, and which of this collection's claims each one would settle. Two of the four fields asked for turn out to be worth less than the asking implied, and one was never asked for at all.