Phyllotaxis
the spirals are counted, not admired
Series

Mechanism claims — the series

3 essays on one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. Which patterns grow on a ring of circumference 0.80. Modes 2 to 8 have positive growth rates and mode 4 is fastest. Integrating the full equations from a disordered start gives 4 peaks.

    What a mechanism would have to show

    Every model of phyllotaxis comes with the caveat that reproducing a pattern is not explaining it. That is easy to repeat and hard to make precise. Here it is made precise — a list of what an account of phyllotaxis would have to establish, with each item marked according to whether the models drawn in these essays establish it.

    part 3 · mechanism
  2. Three disturbances, three places to get in. The rule reads its neighbours, builds a profile of the energy at every azimuth, takes the least of it, and records a position. jostle noise enters at the neighbours; placement noise enters at the record. Two of the three are upstream of the choice and can change which minimum is taken; the third is downstream and never can.

    A growing organ is part of the rule

    Every model in the earlier essays places primordia on a surface and then treats the surface as furniture. But the surface grows between one placement and the next, and that growth reaches the rule through the only channel it has — where the neighbours are. What looks like a boundary condition turns out to be a term in the model.

    part 4 · mechanism
  3. The same lattice with no rule in it. A cylindrical lattice at a divergence of 137.826° and a rise of 0.005, built by placing node i at exactly i times the divergence and then displacing each azimuth independently by 0.5°. Its photograph is the photograph of the stem in the figure beside it and its parastichy pair is the same pair. The largest comb mean in it is 0.03 against a sampling band of 0.07, and the readout refuses.

    A comb is evidence of a rule

    Build the same lattice kinematically — every node at an exact multiple of the divergence, an independent error on each azimuth, no feedback anywhere — and the spectrum is empty. The photograph is identical and the parastichy pair is identical. The comb is not a property of the arrangement.

    part 5 · mechanism

All series