Ladder

Ablation — the ladder

3 distinct arguments against one idea, from the one that introduces it to the one that assumes the rest.
  1. moved 16.4°open ring: where the next organ was going · filled: where it goes · large open circle: the organ removedrise 0.005 · cut 8 back · height ×6generated from a stated rule, not drawn to look right

    The organ that was taken away

    Every observable this site has is read off an arrangement that was finished before the reading began, and the last phase showed what that costs. So remove one primordium from a settled stem and place the next one against what is left. The rule has to answer. The rival account cannot, because in it no organ's position was ever computed from its neighbours.

    rung 1 · mechanism
  2. organ removed, counted back from the tiphow far the next organ moves, in degrees1138.0°284.4°353.4°4167.6°529.3°6101.7°7120.7°816.4°9165.2°1056.7°1181.1°12140.6°132.6°— the front ends here140.0°150.0°160.5°rise 0.005 · pair 8/13generated from a stated rule, not drawn to look right

    The experiment this site can specify

    For eight phases the outstanding item has been a survey — photographs, a protractor, hundreds of specimens — and it has not been done. The intervention is a different kind of ask, and a cheaper one: a needle, one apex, and a yes-or-no per ablation. Here is what it would cost, what it would settle, and the four ways it could come out.

    rung 2 · wrong
  3. 100200300050100organs placed after the removaldivergence, in degreescycle of 8rise 0.005 · cut 8 backgenerated from a stated rule, not drawn to look right

    A rule that cannot heal a hole

    The placement rule corrects itself against a displacement — that is what the lag-one correlation of −0.6 has been saying for three phases. It does not correct itself against a deletion. Which organ is removed decides whether the stem is back on its lattice in twenty-four organs or never, and the boundary between the two is sharp, reproducible and in the middle of the front.

    rung 3 · emergence

All ladders