Phyllotaxis
the spirals are counted, not admired
Concept

Hurwitz's theorem — where it appears

The result bounding how well any irrational number can be approximated by fractions, with the bound attained by the golden ratio. It is the precise statement behind the claim that the golden angle is the most irrational, and it does not single that number out alone.

Named by 5 essays across 2 fields — each of them below, with the objects they name alongside it.

The version of the claim that does survive measurement. The golden angle scores 0.4377, against 0.3462 for the best of 938 other angles sampled. The dashed line is Hurwitz's 1/√5, which no number can exceed.

The claim that survives

Of the three famous assertions about this subject, one is out by a factor of two, one is true of a branch rather than of plants, and one is right — in a sharper form than the version usually told, and about arithmetic rather than about packing.

wrong · Hurwitz The disorder of a head against its divergence angle, 900 points. μ₂ is the mean squared departure of a Voronoi cell's side count from six, measured on 900 points inside 86% of the radius. Swept across 1.32° it is a staircase: flat over stretches of a few hundredths of a degree, with sharp steps between them and narrow deep dips wherever a rational falls. At 137.143° — which is 360 × 8/21 — it is 0.025; At 137.882° — which is 360 × 18/47 — it is 0.125; At 138.002° — which is 360 × 23/60 — it is 0.089. The golden angle is marked and sits at 0.253, in the middle of a flat stretch and nowhere near the largest value on the range.

The most irrational is not the most disordered

If rational angles make ordered tissue, the most badly approximable angle should make the most disordered — which would at last give the golden angle a criterion it wins. Swept across the interval it is the most irrational point of, μ₂ peaks at 138.42° and the golden angle sits unremarkably in the middle.

wrong · Second statistic The cell area a 137.508° golden head's packing is divided by, at 10 sizes. Counting every bounded cell the mean area runs from 3.607 to 38.828, the largest at 150 organs, because the cells just inside the edge of the head reach out to circumcentres far beyond it. Leaving out every cell whose polygon crosses the head's own radius, it stays between 3.1425 and 3.1634 at every size drawn, which is π, the area the square-root rule gives each organ.

Packing, measured against the interior

An earlier reading of these heads reported that no packing criterion singles out the golden angle and that three criteria give three winners. Every one of those readings was divided by a mean cell area that, on a head of 150 organs, was 38.8 where the interior's is π. Divided by the interior's own, the criteria about distance put the golden angle first of 72 angles and the criteria about cells go to rational ones.

tissue · Packing Every angle whose counts from 34 to 144 resist approximation within a per cent of the golden angle's. Over the counts a head shows from 34 to 144, an angle scores like the golden angle when those counts add up, each the sum of the two before, from a first pair near the golden ratio. 46 angles between 20° and 180° come within one per cent of its score of 0.44718, each drawn as a stem at its angle. The five nearest are 137.51° with counts 34, 55, 89, 144 at 100.000 per cent; 99.50° with counts 47, 76, 123 at 99.989 per cent; 106.45° with counts 44, 71, 115 at 99.931 per cent; 151.14° with counts 50, 81, 131 at 99.919 per cent; 132.18° with counts 49, 79, 128 at 99.907 per cent. The golden angle is the highest, and the Lucas angle at 99.50° is a ten-thousandth of the score behind it.

What a head can mean by most irrational

Hurwitz's bound, the one famous claim about this subject that survives, is a limit over every denominator, and a head shows only the counts between its innermost spirals and its rim. Over those counts an angle resists approximation like the golden angle exactly when the counts it shows add up, each the sum of the two before, from a pair near the golden ratio — and every such pair has an angle of its own. The golden angle still scores highest over every window measured, by a ten-thousandth: over counts from 34 to 144 the Lucas angle is 99.989 per cent of it and forty-six angles are within one per cent. What separates the golden angle from them is below the counts they share, at the centre of the head.

wrong · Hurwitz The first organs of a golden head, a Lucas head and a head at 104.67°, with each one's closest pair. The organs within a radius of 7.2 of three Vogel heads — the first 51 organs after the one at the centre — at the golden angle, the Lucas angle and 104.67°, three of the forty-six angles whose counts from 34 to 144 resist approximation within a per cent of the golden angle's. The joined pair in each is its closest: organs 1 and 4, 1.602 apart, at the golden angle; 1 and 5, 1.574 apart, at the Lucas angle; 12 and 19, 1.241 apart, at 104.67°. Out here the three are already different drawings; by a radius of seventeen they are not.

The first three hundred organs

Over the counts a head shows, forty-five angles resist approximation within a per cent as well as the golden angle, and what separates them is at the centre. Grown as heads and measured there, the golden angle has the widest closest pair of all forty-six — by organs 1 and 4, the count its arithmetic names — and keeps first place only while the centre is in the reading. Its rivals stay a per cent apart from it out to a radius that tracks where their spiral counts start to add up, and every one of them is within a per cent by the 289th organ. By the largest hole it is never the best.

wrong · Hurwitz

Named alongside it

The objects these essays reach for when they reach for this one.

Noble numberContinued fractionConvergentsDivergence angleHonest limitsRational approximationClaim testingφ, the golden ratioFibonacciLucas numbersNearest neighbourRational angle

All concepts